Boards › Forum › Where does VS stand on the big issue?
The Don
7138 posts
Yes, I'm referring to the ongoing battle between cake and pie. We, as a guild, need to decide if we're pro-pie or pro-cake. Hopefully this doesn't tear the guild apart but we need to put an end to this hot debate.
Votes are made public so expect to be singled out and ridiculed.
Votes are made public so expect to be singled out and ridiculed.
Aeryssa
838 posts
10-09-2007 10:44am
Did we ever truly decide where cheesecake falls? That's my deciding factor... the people need to know!
Lemmin
2078 posts
10-09-2007 10:47am
Dude, there are people in the world who swing both ways.
Amonsul
3228 posts
10-09-2007 11:11am
.....we need to put an end to this hot debate.
LOL, That's a good one.
LOL, That's a good one.
The Don
7138 posts
Did we ever truly decide where cheesecake falls?
According to wikipedia and Everything2.com, it's a pie.
http://everything2.com/index.pl?node_id=1319751
Dude, there are people in the world who swing both ways.
There's a cake/pie genie and he'll only grant you one but he'll make you any kind you want. Which do you pick?
I like cake too but if I HAD to choose... it'd be a pie.
Hecktigol
4417 posts
10-09-2007 12:51pm
Cake is so much better and...Cheesecake is CAKE!!! :)
edit: ok I saw wikipedia. If it is infact a pie then I like both. Everyone has to have an exception right? Cake all the time unless it is cheesecake aka pie :(
edit: ok I saw wikipedia. If it is infact a pie then I like both. Everyone has to have an exception right? Cake all the time unless it is cheesecake aka pie :(
Sapphyre
12995 posts
Can we have another choice. Like "don't care"?
/e runs and hides from the linching mob
/e runs and hides from the linching mob
Aeryssa
838 posts
10-09-2007 2:31pm
So then by Alton Brown's definition of Cheesecake, Icecream Cake isn't cake either, just awesome icecream yumminess with cookie crumb crust, which makes it Icecream Pie. Hmm, that just sounds weird really.
Linnaris
1840 posts
Ice cream cake can be actual layers of cake with ice cream in it, too.
I just don't know what's true anymore, this debate has turned all that I know about dessert on its ear!
I just don't know what's true anymore, this debate has turned all that I know about dessert on its ear!
Stranger
1533 posts
10-09-2007 3:13pm
Chocolate ancho cake with raspberry filling and whipped raspberry cocoa icing.
Mille crepe cake -- twenty delicate crepes layered with creme anglaise, topped with caramelized sugar.
Individual molten chocolate cake with ice cream.
Orange sponge cake with frosting made of orange and lemon zest whipped into cream.
Do not mess with me on cakes.
Mille crepe cake -- twenty delicate crepes layered with creme anglaise, topped with caramelized sugar.
Individual molten chocolate cake with ice cream.
Orange sponge cake with frosting made of orange and lemon zest whipped into cream.
Do not mess with me on cakes.
Hecktigol
4417 posts
10-09-2007 3:15pm
Just want to say that the poll right now is 8-8. 50% to 50% :)
Shadian
3317 posts
Cake!!!! (unless it's keylime pie or cheesecake)
Oriole
2096 posts
10-09-2007 3:16pm
You are making me so hungery Stranger!
I wish there was an option for "Both". I hate to choose between them! I love them both so much! :(
I wish there was an option for "Both". I hate to choose between them! I love them both so much! :(
Rastus
6166 posts
10-09-2007 3:18pm
Yeah, this is a toughie, but when I really think hard about it, I guess my favorite desserts are pecan pie, pumpkin pie, and any type of cobbler or crumble (yum buttery crunchy sweet doughy things on top) so I had to run with "pie" -- but I'll never turn down a piece of cake!
Lux_Lisbon
11443 posts
Oh so now a stack of crepes is "cake." This can't be true!
Oriole
2096 posts
10-09-2007 5:58pm
Once you put icing on something it automatically becomes "Cake". And once you pour maple syrup on something it automatically becomes "Canadian"! LOL
gifchick
1066 posts
10-09-2007 6:03pm
Can't all desserts just get along as one in my tummy?? I mean really when they all come out they all look the same :P
Oriole
2096 posts
10-09-2007 6:04pm
Can't all desserts just get along as one in my tummy?? I mean really when they all come out they all look the same :P
A good point!
A good point!
Arolaide
2380 posts
10-09-2007 6:41pm
Oh so now a stack of crepes is "cake." This can't be true!
You know what I want? Nutella crepes.
You know what I want? Nutella crepes.
Shadian
3317 posts
"If you see candles in a cake its someone's birthday. If you see candles in a pie then grandmas drunk in the kitchen!"
-Jim Gaffigan
-Jim Gaffigan
Ingomar
1030 posts
10-09-2007 7:11pm
The really important question is, "Did Jam bake it?"
Because then it doesn't matter if it's cake or pie, I am going to eat it.
Because then it doesn't matter if it's cake or pie, I am going to eat it.
Lux_Lisbon
11443 posts
Nutella. Crepes. With bananas on top. Oooooh, Aro....:drool:
Arolaide
2380 posts
10-09-2007 8:22pm
The really important question is, "Did Jam bake it?"
Because then it doesn't matter if it's cake or pie, I am going to eat it.
Probably by dropping your entire face in it.
Because then it doesn't matter if it's cake or pie, I am going to eat it.
Probably by dropping your entire face in it.
Jorack
754 posts
10-09-2007 9:19pm
Cake or Pie? Why do we have to choose? I say both. Now normally I'd side with cake, but the pumpkin pie last weekend (Cdn Thanksgiving) was very good. ;-)
Ingomar
1030 posts
10-09-2007 10:02pm
Probably by dropping your entire face in it.
I find that this way is the best way to ensure I get the ENTIRE thing.
I find that this way is the best way to ensure I get the ENTIRE thing.
