I was wondering if there is any general concensus on the best choice between Aldor and Scyers for Warrior and Preist.

I went with Aldor on my hunter without doing much research and some say that was not the best choice. I have not yet chosen with my 67 Warrior or my 58 Preist. Any suggestions?

I'd say pick based upon your crafting skill, honestly. Or pick the shoulder enchant you want most.

The weapons you can buy at revered are largely interchangeable with weapons you can get from level 70 group quests, and will be replaced by gear from Kara.

The enchants are pretty awesome for both factions. If there's one you like, go for that faction.

The crafting stuff is also good. At least for tailors. Aldor tailors will have an easier time leveling up their skill than Scryer tailors.

There's a good comparison at wowwiki

I choose Aldor for Rin basically because of the Inscription of Warding. The Aldor favors Dodge while the Scryer favors Defense. It's incredibly easy to hit the 490 defense cap without the inscription and a warrior can never have too much Dodge! With Black Smithing, Aldor is pretty much +FR while Scryer is +AR. If your main tanking, you'll probably never wear any of it anyways.

I picked scryers on my rogue. I forget why, lol. I probably should have picked aldor. I was unsure which to pick on my hunter untill I saw they had there own access to Nagrand and they had Lightwarden's Band
I really wanted that on my hunter.

I picked Aldor because it starts with an A. I AM THE BEST GAMER EVER.

I chose Scryer because I'm an alchemist, and I thought their inscription was more useful to me at the time.

I chose Scryer because I'm an alchemist, and I thought their inscription was more useful to me at the time.

Ditto that. Scryers had an alchie recipe, Aldor didn't. That made the decision for Shaerl pretty easy. :)

The biggest difference between the two, really, is that Scryers eat poop, while Aldors rulez. That's what it all comes down to. Do you want to eat poop, or do you want to rulez?

I want to rule.

This is a good thing to look at http://www.wowwiki.com/Comparison_of_Aldor_and_Scryer_rewards/Crafting_Recipes